Government Proposes Major School Food Standards Overhaul

Finally, we have some great school food news! The government has just proposed the most significant overhaul of school food standards in nearly two decades. Providing better school food is the most positive news for every family in Britain.

For busy parents who rely on school meals to help carry their children through the day, these changes in both primary and secondary schools could make a real difference. School food makes up around a third of a child’s daily nutrition and, after years of campaigning from parents, teachers and health professionals, it really does feel as though the message has finally been heard.

Get our lovely Healthy Bites newsletter!

Each week, you’ll get an amazing recipe, a useful health tip, and an ingredient to jazz up your shopping basket!

In clinical practice, we see just how much families are juggling every day. With two working parents now the norm rather than the exception, finding time to cook nutritious meals from scratch every day is often a real challenge. School meals are not a fallback and for millions of children, they are the most reliably balanced meal of the day. Getting them right and feeding them the good stuff matters enormously, not just for their physical and metabolic health, but also for children’s focus, mood, behaviour and their ability to learn.

The Department for Education launched its consultation on 13th April for both primary and secondary schools, alongside an example secondary school lunch menu showing what the new standards could look like in practice. I have read both documents carefully, and the overall picture is very encouraging, with one or two areas worth keeping an eye on.

Why are school food standards being updated?

The current school food standards were introduced in 2008 following the famous Jamie Oliver campaign that shocked the nation into paying attention to what children were actually eating in school canteens (luckily, there have been no Turkey Twizzlers since then!). For their time, those standards were a real step forward, but a lot has changed since then, and our understanding of nutrition, gut health and the relationship between food and brain function has advanced considerably. Also, child obesity, poor health and developmental delays have exploded in recent years, and so more help is needed from the top down to help nourish our kids with healthier options.

The government’s consultation acknowledges this, and its stated aims include making the standards clearer and more practical for schools to implement. This includes reducing ultra-processed food, bringing standards in line with current dietary guidance and, most importantly, addressing the gap between what schools are technically required to serve and what children actually end up eating. On paper, this all sounds very positive, and in several areas it really is.

What the new proposals get right

A stronger focus on whole foods

The proposed standards place greater emphasis on whole, minimally processed foods. There is clearer guidance on vegetables, beans and pulses, and wholegrains, which support gut microbiome diversity, steady blood sugar, and sustained cognitive function. Children’s brains need a consistent supply of glucose from complex carbohydrates, not the rollercoaster that comes with refined starches and sugary snacks.

Tighter restrictions on salt and saturated fat

The new proposals tighten existing limits on salt and saturated fat across school meals by cutting out fried foods such as chips, battered fish and chicken nuggets and reducing pizza to only once a week. Given that cardiovascular disease risks begin in childhood, and that excessive salt in early life contributes to hypertension risk later on, this is a sensible move. Research published in the British Journal of Nutrition has consistently shown that dietary habits established during school years tend to persist into adulthood.

Clearer labelling and allergen guidance

The consultation also proposes improved transparency around ingredients and allergens. For the growing number of children managing food sensitivities (whether a diagnosed allergy, coeliac disease, or an intolerance), clearer information at the point of service makes a real practical difference. I look forward to seeing more details on this angle, as so many kids living with allergies get offered a baked potato with baked beans or tuna every day on repeat right now – which is not only boring, but eating the same lunch every day is not helping to support their gut health and microbiome diversity that they so crucially need.

Limits on the sweet stuff

Sweets, chocolate bars and sugary drinks will be more tightly restricted under the new framework, with only one sweet pudding being offered a week. Puddings the rest of the week will be fruit, yoghurts or puddings that contain at least 50% fruit.

This is unambiguously good news as the evidence linking high sugar intake in children to obesity, dental decay, attention difficulties and mood swings is substantial and widely accepted in nutritional research For instance, a 14-year study of around 3,000 children published in the Journal of Attention Disorders found a significant link between high sugar diets and focus-related difficulties. Removing these from the school meal environment reduces any temptation to gorge on the sweet stuff and also normalises healthier choices.

What about artificial sweeteners?

One area worth keeping an eye on is the proposal to permit artificially sweetened drinks as substitutes for sugary ones. The intention is sound, but the science is more complicated than it might appear. A 2022 study published in Cell found that common sweeteners such as sucralose and saccharin directly alter the gut microbiome and can impair blood sugar regulation. For children, whose microbiomes are still developing, this is worth taking seriously, and I really hope that artificial sugars do not dominate the school food space with these plans.

In my clinical experience, children who regularly consume artificially sweetened drinks, jelly, and pre-packed sugar-free sweet puddings tend to maintain a stronger preference for sweet tastes and find it harder to enjoy naturally flavoured foods and plain water. We hope the final standards will reflect the research by keeping water and milk as the drinks of choice in schools.

What about the example secondary school menu?

The example secondary school lunch menu published alongside the consultation is worth looking at. Here are some of the lunches they suggest:

Spaghetti bolognese with tomato and mozzarella salad
Chicken and houmous wrap
Saag paneer with pilau rice
Roasted chickpea, roasted vegetables, sundried tomato and mozzarella wrap

These will be served with fresh seasonal salad and vegetables available every day. And then tropical fruit salad, strawberries, grapes and yoghurts fresh daily for pudding.

Recommended drinks are water, flavoured water that is sugar-free, fruit-flavoured still drinks with no added sugar (can include sweeteners), semi-skimmed or skimmed milk or lactose-free milk, plain soya, oat and rice drinks, and tea & coffee.

There are clear positives such as more vegetables, better protein options and fewer obvious junk foods. But look carefully and you’ll also spot sweetened squash and flavoured low-sugar drinks appearing as standard drink choices, as well as skimmed and semi-skimmed milk which is not as satiating or wholesome as whole milk.

Other areas that could go further

Ultra-processed food remains broadly permitted

While the new standards do tighten some restrictions, ultra-processed foods remain broadly permitted provided they meet the nutrient criteria set by the government. UPFs are defined by the NOVA classification system as industrially formulated products containing ingredients not typically found in a home kitchen.

The problem is that nutrient profiling misses many of the harmful properties of ultra-processed foods such as their effects on gut permeability, their effect on the microbiome, the inflammatory signalling triggered by emulsifiers and additives, and the dopamine-hijacking effects of their palatability.

A child eating a school meal that technically meets all the nutrient targets might still be consuming a meal that’s undermining their gut health, their attention and their mood.

Omega-3 fatty acids are underemphasised

Given the robust body of evidence linking omega-3 fatty acids, particularly DHA and EPA from oily fish, to better metabolic health, brain development, attention and emotional regulation in children, the proposals miss an opportunity to mandate more oily fish as part of the weekly food offerings at school.

The research from Dr Alex Richardson and her team at FAB Research at Oxford University has consistently shown that omega-3 intake is one of the most important nutritional factors in childhood mental health and cognitive performance.

Salmon curries, teriyaki salmon poke bowls or fish tacos on Fridays, could be a solution to this problem.

What you can do right now

Whether these proposals pass as they are currently written or are modified through the consultation process, there are practical steps you can take at home to support your child’s nutrition and to make your voice heard.

Get involved in the consultation

The consultation is open to responses from parents, schools and health professionals. If you have concerns, particularly about the artificial sweetener provisions, this is the time to say so. You can access the full consultation document at the Department for Education consultation page.

Work on their home diet

School food is one part of the picture and often only 5 out of 21 meals a week. What children eat before and after school and at weekends can significantly offset or compound the effects of what they eat during the school day. So, you can focus in on feeding them:

Oily fish or shellfish twice a week (sardines, mackerel, salmon, prawns) for their omega-3 intake.
Give them plenty of cultured foods like natural yoghurt and kefir to support their gut microbiome diversity.
Feed them the rainbow of fruits and vegetables daily and don’t rely on them getting their ‘five a day’ from school food.
Replace sweetened drinks entirely with water, milk, diluted fruit juice, or herbal teas.
Give them a high-quality protein at breakfast to stabilise their blood sugar and optimise their focus and performance throughout the school day.

Talk to your school

Many schools want to do better and simply lack the knowledge or external pressure to prioritise nutrition. Sharing this information with your headteacher, PTA or school catering team, kindly and constructively, can plant important seeds. When schools bring nutrition education into the curriculum, children get on board too. From the workshops my team and I have delivered at a broad range of schools, the enthusiasm for healthier, tastier food is off the scale, and this is what kids want!

Round up

This is a landmark moment for children’s health in Britain, and it’s a great sign. More whole foods, less sugar, better allergen support and clearer standards across the school day. These are changes that will hopefully benefit millions of children, and particularly those whose families are doing their best in difficult circumstances. When parents are working full-time and time is short, knowing that a nutritious, well-balanced meal is waiting for their child at school is a relief to so many.

Children spend a significant portion of their waking hours and eating at school. The standards we set for that environment shape not just their health today but their relationship with food, their gut microbiome development, and their long-term wellbeing. These proposals get the big things right, and that is worth acknowledging wholeheartedly.

If you’d like to understand more about how your child’s nutrition is affecting their focus, mood, behaviour or energy levels, the NatureDoc clinical team can help. If they have multiple allergies or are highly selective eaters and you are worried about how to ensure that they are getting all the nutrients they need, get in touch to book a consultation, and we’ll work together to develop a tailored plan that supports your child to feel and function at their best.

The proposed new school food standards – what every parent needs to know